Book Review: The Walled City

The Walled City

The Walled City by Ryan Graudin

Genre: Young-Adult, Crime, Fantasy, Gangsters

The Review

“There are three rules in the Walled City: Run fast. Trust no one. Always carry your knife. Right now, my life depends completely on the first. Run, run, run.”

These are the words that drew me in from the blurb of this book. In all honesty, I was unsure about a book that talked of rape, drug culture, gangsters, crime, death and prostitution, never mind the fact that it is a young-adult book. However, that does not mean to say I feel it is wrong for such a book to be published under the young-adult genre. After all, the term includes ‘adult’, the term only refers to somebody slightly below adult years and we have to enable our youth to learn and be educated through some means, and we cannot continue to hide the world from them. So I think whilst this book is gritty, harsh and at times dark and discomforting, it is a book that holds meaning, honesty and a brutal reflection of what human nature can lead to, and I think it is a fabulous addition to the young-adult genre as not the typical read.

The Walled City was unexpected in so many ways. It focused on three youths, Jin, Mei Yee and Dai. They all had secrets, all had a past and the alternate POVS throughout the novel slowly began to unravel their lives, their pasts, their hopes, dreams and needs and I really connected with all three of them. Personally I felt the strongest connection with Jin who is out in the Walled City to find her sister. She is young, but she is determined, feisty and frankly I would not want to mess with this young fireball. She is an absolutely brilliant character and my heart throughout the novel was firmly rooting for her. That is exactly what I want books I read to do too, have me rooting for the main character and living the story with them.

Dai is a mystery, and not exactly the one I expected. He is a likeable, rather tortured character, but underneath the first impression of a prickly, mysterious and rather untrustworthy exterior, he also found a place in my heart.

Mei Yee is the character I connected least with, however I feel that is because we got to know her least. By the end I could see her as an equally strong individual as Jin and Dai, but she faced her own struggles, being sold into prostitution at an early age by her father and being locked in one building for her future, it does appear that she lives a dismal life. There are no real explicit descriptions of the prostitution or lewd events in the brothel, however there are a couple of rather sadistic moments of brutality from a customer and the master to be aware of.

Throughout the novel Graudin is challenging how human nature has allowed this ‘Walled City’ to be created which is a place untouched by the laws of society and police force so that drugs, crime and death can continue. It challenges how human nature can become so depraved. Despite all of this, underneath it are shining moments of friendship, determination, a genuine care for others, doing the right thing and family.

There is a small amount of romance in the novel, but honestly it is not the dominant aspect, in fact it is entirely limited in terms of the plot. This is one of the other reasons why I really enjoyed this novel, because it was a somewhat refreshing look at the young-adult genre without the dominant aspect being romance. It was about friendship, family and trusting others with not just emotions, but your life. Having said that, the romance was entrancing, well-written and it was genuinely built up to. I thought it fit into the narrative with a fluid ease and was not forced in the slightest.

When I finished this novel and found out Graudin had based her novel in part upon a place called Kowloon’s Walled City in Hong Kong which in some ways made her question the type of people that would be there and the happenings, it made it all seem more realistic and heart-wrenching. Obviously the novel is fictitious which leads to the kind of fantasy element, because I would struggle to label this city as ‘contemporary’. Although the genre labelling is one topic that I struggled with when it came to this novel. Despite all this, Graudin is making a clear statement against human trafficking and I appreciated the message of the novel.

Overall, The Walled City was a novel that sent my emotions into turmoil, tugged on my heartstrings and had me racing through the last part of the novel. I almost certainly applaud Graudin on tackling such a sensitive topic, not being afraid to delve into the grit and darkness of humanity and coming out the other side successfully with 5 shining stars that shows human nature is not all bad. An absolutely phenomenal addition to the young-adult genre, and so splendidly written that every word despite being full of grit and tension, was quite beautiful to read; I recommend it to you all!

Survival Chances: 87%

Expiration Date: 2095

Favourite Quotes *quotes taken from an earc subject to change on publication

But there are still more wishes in my soul than there are stars. I wish I could hold Jin Ling’s hand in mine, I wish Sing never tried to run. I wish the boy didn’t make my chest burn, make my thoughts soar like a phoenix. I wish every girl in this brothel could be one of the lucky ones. I wish, like the boy, I was somewhere else. Someone else. And on and on and on.

“I work alone,” I say quickly. I do everything alone: eat, sleep, run, steal, talk, cry. It’s the curse of the second rule: Trust no one. The cost of staying alive.”

We stay like this for a long time. Skin to skin under false stars. The ones that never fall.

Rating: 5 / 5 stars

Goodreads ~ Amazon UK / US ~ Author’s Website


Filed under 2014 Publication, 5 Books, Crime, E-book, Fantasy, Little, Brown and Company, Ryan Graudin, Young Adult

18 responses to “Book Review: The Walled City

  1. Great review! I’ve been on the fence about this one just because I absolutely hated her other book. However, I’m glad you enjoyed it! I may check it out now!

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      I definitely think this one will be different to the other book from reading the premise. I think the author has come a long way. I hope you choose to check it out! 🙂

  2. This sounds interesting. I don’t mind YA books being gritty and full of adult themes if handled correctly, and from what you say, it appears that was done in this book.

  3. Good to hear it is emotional and surprised you in that good way

  4. Zoe

    5 stars?!?! YEPEE! This is such an anticipated read for me because I absolutely love the premise and the diverse vibe it gives off; and I’m so glad to hear it impressed you so much! 😀 You’ve definitely made me even MORE excited to read this – if that’s even possible! 😉 Thanks for sharing, and wonderful review! ❤

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      Awww thank you. I am so pleased to hear that I have made you more excited. It is always fabulous for me when I am capable of sharing my love for a book with others. I definitely have to say it is a diverse vibe!

  5. Melanie (YA Midnight Reads)

    Wow 5 stars! Damn… I am getting really pumped up about this one now. I wasn’t so sure about this one before, because I hated her first novel, All the Glows, but I like the new concept she has here, maybe she is a good writer after all!

    Fab review <33

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      I had a look at her first book and I think there are a very different kind of concept and style, so hopefully you will enjoy reading this one much more than her previous novel!

  6. Oh. My. Goodness. This. Book. Sounds. Epic. I’d seen it around the blogosphere quite a bit but never really been enamoured with it. BUT EVERYTHING HAS CHANGED! I’m so so glad that it surprised you and you enjoyed it so much 😀 Brilliant review, Livvy 🙂

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      Thank you, Rebekah! I am so pleased to hear I could change your mind about reading it and I really hope you love it as much as I do when you get around to reading! 🙂

  7. Oo, good to know about this one! I had been excited when I first saw it and then wasn’t sure. I can’t handle something too dark currently, but I’ll keep it in mind when I’m feeling for something intense and gritty 🙂

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      I hope your excitement returns when you are in the mood for something gritty because it is a seriously good read! 🙂

  8. Marianne @ Boricuan Bookworms

    I was hesitant about this one, but not anymore! Wow 5 stars. I am very curious about the quotes you shared throughout! I want to read an emotion provoking book! Ha. Great review! 🙂

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      I hope you enjoy this one if you decide to check it out and I’ll be looking out for your thoughts! Thanks! 🙂

  9. Woah – high praise!! Seriously so exciting reading this because I have also been very curious about this one ever since I read that blurb (and saw the gorgeous cover) so I’m quite pleased that you loved it so! Cannot wait to read this now!!

    • Livvy @The Absent Historian

      Wooo! I am pleased to hear so many people are excited for this one now because it is a seriously good read. I hope you enjoy it just as much as me! 🙂

Thanks for dropping by, I really appreciate every single view. If you're a fellow blogger I'll return follows/comments. Unfortunately this is an award and tag free zone because of time constraints, but I appreciate the thought.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s